Turn Shoppers into Brand Advocates

Turning shoppers into brand advocates transforms the customer lifecycle into a profit-generating flywheel.

An ecommerce customer lifecycle is a process with steps. It’s different from a flywheel, a model of continuous improvement. Combined, they create a reinforcing loop that produces customers and revenue.

Diagram of a customer lifecycle flywheel with five stages: Engage, Acquire, Nurture, Retain, Encourage Advocacy.

A customer lifecycle flywheel drives sales in a loop that improves with every rotation.

Ecommerce Customer Lifecycle

A customer lifecycle generally has five broad steps — from discovering a brand or product to becoming an advocate for the business.

Ecommerce marketers often focus on one or two of these steps. For example, some marketers spend most of their time engaging and acquiring shoppers. This is essential work but unending.

Marketers relying on advertising to engage customers will never eliminate paid acquisition or reduce its cost. Growth will be proportional to investment.

In contrast, the same marketers could develop brand advocates and soon find steps one (Engage) and two (Acquire) filled with referred shoppers.

By no means should ecommerce stores stop advertising. But they should think of customer lifecycles as flywheels.

Connecting Stages

Business flywheels have rules. First, the virtuous cycle means each flywheel step moves smoothly to the next. For example, many marketing teams are good at moving shoppers from engagement (Engage) to purchase (Acquire).

Portion of the flywheel showing the Engage and Acquire steps.

Each step in a business flywheel should flow smoothly into the next.

A prospect moves from the Engage step to Acquire when she has enough context to make a purchase. Ecommerce marketing teams are usually very good at this part of the wheel. They run ads, monitor clicks and visitors, and measure conversions.

Moving a shopper from Acquire to Nurture should be just as smooth. Perhaps this requires a post-purchase email sequence encouraging the shopper to join a newsletter. Or it may be a thank-you note from the store.

Each step should lead to the next. Encourage Advocacy becomes the final step, leading back to Engage. The store’s advocates have become marketers, exposing potential customers to the business. Thus Engage now includes both referred and purchased shoppers.

Portion of the flywheel showing the Encourage Advocacy and Acquire steps.

Encourage Advocacy, the last step in a business flywheel, restarts the cycle.

Ease

The second rule of a business flywheel is each rotation is easier. This becomes true when marketers focus on the entire cycle and encourage advocacy.

Here is a hypothetical example. What if every brand advocate produced one prospect for each rotation of the flywheel? Assuming the company ordinarily obtains 100 engaged shoppers each cycle, advocacy could lead to 47 more engaged shoppers by the fifth rotation.

With brand advocates, the top of the cycle (Engage) is growing because customers beget customers.

Effectiveness

The third rule for a business flywheel is each rotation is more effective.

This, too, is true when marketers consider the entire lifecycle.

In the example above, more prospects are entering the Engage step, and thus more into Acquire, Nurture, Retain, and Encourage Advocacy.

Flywheel

A linear conversion process implies an ending. Marketers often focus on the steps that conclude with immediate sales. But transform that process into a flywheel, and suddenly advocacy is not the end but the beginning of greater opportunity.

Develop promotional tactics for each step in the cycle. The increased flow boosts revenue and profit without more investment.

Abandoned Carts Are an Opportunity

Abandoned cart recovery can be a goldmine for ecommerce marketers, but not how one might think.

In 2024, ecommerce shopping cart abandonment rates among U.S. adults hover around 70%, according to the Baymard Institute. It’s a big opportunity.

Baymard suggests focusing on design, noting that “if we focus only on checkout usability issues which we…have documented to be solvable, the average large-sized ecommerce site can gain a 35% increase in conversion rate though better checkout design.”

For the overall U.S. and E.U. ecommerce industry, that 35% increase is about $260 billion in additional revenue.

Beyond Design

The problem is that usability and design haven’t solved abandonment thus far. Ecommerce cart abandonment rates have been essentially flat since 2018 and have risen since 2006.

Ecommerce managers have been unable to solve the shopping cart abandonment problem, or the rate does not have the impact on sales we think it might.

What if shopping cart abandonment is normal for ecommerce, and the real opportunity rests in treating folks who abandon carts like warm leads instead of lost opportunities?

That does not mean that online merchants should ignore design or conversion optimization; rather, it implies an opportunity to market to shoppers who didn’t complete the checkout process.

Cart Recovery Email

A cart abandonment email sequence is perhaps the most popular and effective way to recover the sale. Ecommerce platforms such as Shopify and BigCommerce include those emails as default features.

Familiarity, however, may be a problem. It may be too easy to turn on the feature without optimizing it. A better practice could be identifying the shopper as early as possible and creating an automated behavior-based email to convert.

The steps could be:

  • Capture the shopper’s email address as soon as possible,
  • Understand when to send the first cart recovery email message,
  • Know how many messages the series should include,
  • Optimize and personalize the message content.

Merchants should test and optimize each step for their audience and setup. For example, some marketers send the first recovery email 90 minutes after the abandonment, but others prefer 30 minutes or less.

Retargeting Ads

Another recovery tactic is to retarget cart abandoners with advertising. Retargeting ads should complement the abandonment email series. When the series begins, it should add the shopper to a retargeting campaign. This requires automation to launch a retargeting campaign and then turn it off.

The campaign should run on Google and Meta and in programmatic email via services such as LiveIntent. The goal is to remind shoppers of the abandoned items.

As always, testing and iterating is the key to remarketing success.

Text Messages

After email, the most powerful ecommerce communication tool is text messaging. Text messages are now the preferred transactional communication channel for many shoppers.

A typical online buyer prefers text-based order and shipping notifications. Marketers can use that affinity to remind shoppers via text about abandoned items. Make the message as transactional as possible and avoid repeated messages.

Better Recovery

Since 2006, ecommerce cart abandonment rates have risen from about 59% to 70%, peaking at almost 72% in 2012 with the rise of smartphones before leveling off.

Yet cart abandonment is an opportunity. Without neglecting design, merchants can improve their recovery efforts with coordinated email, retargeting ads, and text messages.

AI Tools for Ideal Customer Profiles

An “ideal customer profile” describes a company’s most valuable prospects, those who find a product or service seemingly perfect for their needs.

Ideal customer profiles help merchants:

  • Select marketing channels,
  • Create ad copy and design,
  • Narrow outreach,
  • Build email sequences,
  • Produce how-to, problem-solving videos.

AI platforms have vast databases of businesses and their audiences, helpful for defining an ideal customer. I tested three platforms for this article.

Custom GPT: ICP Generator

ICP – Ideal Customer Profile Generator,” a custom GPT (available for ChatGPT Plus subscribers), creates profiles based on a URL. I tested it on Smarty Marketing, the site I launched last year. The results were useful, although lacking specifics. My company’s ideal customers per the custom GPT are:

  • In the growth phase: Companies aiming to expand their online presence, increase website traffic, and enhance brand visibility.
  • Digital forward: Businesses that understand and value digital marketing’s impact on growth and are ready to invest in innovative SEO strategies.
  • In competitive markets: Enterprises in industries where online competition is fierce, making them more likely to benefit from unique and effective SEO and link-building strategies.
  • Content creators: Organizations that produce valuable content and can leverage infographic marketing and social media to engage and expand their audience.
  • Seeking long-term results: Businesses focused on building lasting brand awareness and not just short-term gains, aligning with Smarty Marketing’s emphasis on long-term outcomes.

I could continue prompting the custom GPT for the best keywords in organic and paid search campaigns, the best social media platforms, helpful Facebook audience targeting, and so on.

Lemlist

Lemlist builds free ideal customer profiles based on a URL. The profiles are personas with names, demographic details, goals and objectives, and their potential outreach strategies. The reports are useful for ideas and brainstorming. The most helpful sections are:

  • An ideal customer’s responsibilities and pain points,
  • The ideal customer’s most effective marketing channels (“touchpoints”),
  • Risks to ideal customers of not achieving goals.

Lemlist builds free ideal customer profiles based on a URL — with names, demographic details, goals and objectives, and potential outreach strategies. Click image to enlarge.

For example, Lemlist identified my company’s ideal customer as a marketing director (spot-on) with these pain points:

Struggling with understanding organic search strategies, underperforming marketing campaigns, and lack of unique digital content.

And the risks to my ideal customers of not solving problems are:

Continued decrease in online visibility, inability to compete with competitors’ online presence, loss of potential leads and sales.

M1-Project

M1 Project offers various AI-powered marketing tools, including generators for an ideal customer profile and a marketing strategy. Input your URL and M1 Project will:

  • Create a product description,
  • List the problems your products solve,
  • Segment your target audience.

Edit the descriptions, problems, and segments to your business. Then choose your preferred segment, and the tool will create an ideal customer profile. The downloadable document costs $99 and includes the ideal customer’s:

  • Position, income, and pain points,
  • Tools or platforms (potential partners for your business),
  • Publications,
  • Channels frequented,
  • Followed social media accounts.
Online Shoppers Expect More from Sellers

Ecommerce sellers may be delivering a sub-par shopping experience and not even know it, according to a survey of 1,000 American consumers.

The survey from Deloitte Digital in October 2023 is a good reminder of the longstanding gap in how merchants and shoppers perceive the ecommerce experience.

Photo of a male viewing a smartphone screenPhoto of a male viewing a smartphone screen

Online merchants often overestimate customers’ admiration of shopping experiences.

Perception Gap

If the Deloitte Digital survey is accurate, about 80% of brands selling online “believe consumers are impressed by the online shopping experiences they provide. Yet fewer than half of consumers actually are.”

While that may seem shocking, it is not new.

One could argue that there has always been a gap between the perceptions of business leaders and their customers.

For example, a September 2015 Gartner article stated, “Employees are still seeing a vast gulf between the design and usability of the software they use outside work and the software they use in the workplace.”

The article noted that user-friendly consumer software had set new expectations among employees in the workspace.

Accounting and inventory management software are examples. Makers of that software thought the user experience was good; customers (employees) frequently did not.

Scholars and executives have long sought frameworks to identify the gap. Examples include W.E. Deming’s principles of Total Quality Management in Japan during the 1950s, SERVQUAL (assessing “SERVice” and “QUALity”), Six Sigma, and Net Promoter Score.

Why a Gap?

Having acknowledged the perception gap, we can wonder why.

The likely answer is that customer expectations quickly change. L.L.Bean and Amazon reset expectations when they pioneered free shipping. Soon, free shipping was not enough. It also needed to be fast. Then “fast shipping” evolved from five days to two days to one day, and now even the same day in some locations.

Online merchants — or really ecommerce platform developers — that improve the shopping experience set a new standard for their customers, thus the perception gap.

Take Action

The fact that shoppers always seek a better ecommerce experience should spur businesses to action for two reasons.

First, the gap could widen. Ecommerce sellers and platforms that do not meet shoppers’ expectations risk revenue losses or worse.

Second, closing the perception gap is a competitive opportunity. The Deloitte Digital survey found that “customers spend 37% more with brands they find deliver consistent and positive commerce experiences.”

Hence online sellers should regularly measure shoppers’ perceptions and update features accordingly.

Focus on Fundamentals

Taking action, however, does not mean chasing fads. Focus first on the essentials.

The Deloitte Digital survey identified four key ecommerce features where a perception gap exists, suggesting a selling opportunity.

For each of the four “gap” features, Deloitte reported the percentages of ecommerce businesses that believed shoppers were impressed versus the shoppers who agreed.

Ecommerce Feature or Service Brand Perception Shopper Perception
Clear Inventory Availability 77% 54%
Easy Returns / Exchanges 80% 59%
Proactive Delivery Updates 78% 59%
Accurate Search and Discovery 79% 63%

Sellers should research why they overestimate the shopper’s favorable views.

Take “Accurate Search and Discovery,” which had the smallest perception gap in the survey.

A July 2022 report from the Baymard Institute, a customer-experience research firm, noted that 42% of the 133 “major” ecommerce stores it reviewed had site search issues, such as allowing shoppers to search by product type, i.e., a couch versus a chair.

So even a small perception gap creates opportunities to improve.