Key Levers To Steer AI in Performance Max And Boost Results via @sejournal, @adsliaison

I often see comments to the effect of, “Google just wants you to launch your campaigns and let its systems do everything.”

Let me just say as clearly as I can: no, that’s not what Google wants.

As always, the marketer’s role is evolving, but that role is as important as ever. This also applies to managing successful Performance Max campaigns.

The set up of Performance Max is where you can really position your campaign for success. But that doesn’t mean it’s entirely “set it and forget it.”

You know your or your client’s business better than Google. The inputs you provide, the tests you run, the creative you build, the analysis you perform to continue refining and iterating – those skills are critical to success and standing out from your competitors.

And understanding how the systems work and how to inform them is a big part of what will set you apart as the use of AI in marketing continues to evolve.

Consider Each Of These Levers In Your Performance Max Campaigns

Let’s dive into the features currently available in Performance Max to help you guide the AI and maximize your results.

Bidding Goals And Targets

Performance Max automatically adjusts formats and inventory based on the goals you provide and focuses on auctions that have a high probability of driving results toward your stated campaign goal(s).

That’s why it’s so important to define your goals based on the key performance indicators (KPIs) you want to drive with Performance Max, whether you’re looking to maximize conversions and have a cost per action (CPA) target or want to maximize conversion value and have a return on ad spend (ROAS) target.

If you have goals such as sales revenue, lifetime value, or profit margins, optimizing toward conversion value allows you to tie your bidding strategy more closely to those real business outcomes.

I’m not going to dive into marginal ROI in this article, but if you’re not familiar with the concept and are using Performance Max, I recommend bookmarking this page for later.

Conversion Value Rules

With Conversion Value Rules, you can indicate a higher value audience – as well as location and device – at the campaign level. Performance Max will optimize the bid and assemble the asset combination best predicted to convert for each audience member in real time.

New Customer Acquisition

You can either opt to bid higher for new customers/new customer value, or bid only for new customers/new customer value.

Note that there are some requirements, including needing to have an audience list of at least 1,000 active members in at least one network for the system to be able to identify existing customers.  Which brings us to…

First-party Data

It’s no secret that having a first-party data strategy is an increasingly key part of adapting to the evolving privacy landscape (some helpful resources here).

First-party data is also an important signal for informing Google AI to find more of those valuable customers and enhance your audience strategy.

There are several ways to use your first-party data in Performance Max, such as audience signals, which are covered here.

Brand Suitability

There are a number of brand suitability controls available for Performance Max, including support for all of your account-level content suitability settings.

You can check out the full list here, but I’ll highlight account-level negative keywords, which launched this year.

Performance Max respects account-level negative keywords which prevent your ads from showing for search terms that aren’t suitable for your brand in Search & Shopping inventory.

(Separately, you can also use “excluded content keywords” to prevent ads from serving on search terms on Display or Video inventory.)

Brand Exclusions

There was a lot of advertiser desire for more control over the brand terms Performance Max can show on. That’s where the new brand exclusions come in.

To prevent Performance Max from serving on specific brand terms (your own, competitor, or partner brands) in Search & Shopping, you can now apply a brand list to your campaign.

Campaign-level brand exclusions will apply to most misspellings and brand searches in a foreign language.

Page Feeds

Performance Max now supports page feeds to help you send Search traffic to a specific set of landing page URLs on your site.

You can add page feeds in Business Data to specify the URLs on your website that you want to use in your campaign.

You can also add custom labels to your page feeds to help target your ads and adjust bids per label. Note that you’ll need to enable automatically created text assets to use page feeds in Performance Max.

Final URL Controls For Automatically Created Assets

Automatically created assets in Performance Max generate headlines and descriptions from your landing page, domain, and existing ads and assets when they’re more relevant to a user’s search query and are predicted to improve performance.

When you enable Final URL expansion in automatically created assets, Google Ads will automatically send traffic to the most relevant URL it identifies as likely to improve performance. If you want to direct traffic to specific URLs only, you can uncheck this box.

You can also opt into Final URL and click the link to “exclude some URLs” in order to narrow the options available for URL expansion.

You can either enter specific URLs or use rules to exclude categories of content on your site. This is a helpful lever to steer your budget away from certain types of content, pages that are outdated, etc. More examples here.

Asset Groups

If you want to customize your messaging/assets by audience, products, or category, you can use multiple asset groups. Performance Max will test different combinations and learn which ones perform best for your target audiences.

You can use asset groups to theme products in your Merchant Center feed with listing groups.

There’s a helpful grid on this page that shows the minimum, maximum, and recommended number of assets to include in our asset groups – along with a bunch of other helpful info about asset groups – in this Help Center article.

And a quick reminder that ad strength is a guidepost, not a metric. Ad strength is an indicator of whether your asset group has enough assets to maximize performance across inventory.

The more diverse assets you provide, the more opportunities there will be to show the right ad to potential customers. A wide variety of creative assets – including different sizes and orientations – is key to resonating with different customer needs and mindsets.

New generative AI features, now in beta in the US, will also make it easier to scale your assets.

To understand how your assets are performing, you can use asset reports and asset group reporting (new this year).

When using asset reports, compare like assets to each other – headlines to headlines and descriptions to descriptions – because they are rated in relation to each other. The Combinations tab will show the top six combinations for text, image, and video assets, ranked by performance.

With asset group reporting, you can better understand the contribution of your asset groups for optimization by evaluating your average CPA or ROAS at the asset group level.

You can also select and save additional metrics in your views from the Columns button.

Location, Language, Ad Scheduling

It’s worth noting these standard settings are also available for Performance Max.

Signals

There are currently two signals you can add to your Performance Max campaigns to help jumpstart the learning to find more conversions or conversion value.

Note that signals in Performance Max are not hard targeting constraints. Instead, they’re a tool to indicate what’s relevant to your business to guide the AI.

Search Themes

Launched this fall, Search themes are a new, optional signal you can use to inform the AI about your business to expand relevant reach across all channels, including Search.

You can add up to 25 search themes per Performance Max asset group.

Search themes respect brand exclusions and account-level negative keywords, and are additive to queries that Performance Max would already match to using your URLs, assets, and more.

You can add and remove search themes at any time.

Use search terms insights on the Insights page to know what search term themes your Performance Max ads are showing on.

Audience Signals

Also optional, Performance Max will use audience signals as a starting point to find customers faster. You can add your own data, including site visitors, customers, etc., or interest and demographics as audience signals.

Again, this is not a hard signal, and Performance Max may also find that certain asset combinations convert audiences outside of the ones indicated in your audience signals.

When available, audience insights on the Insights page will show you which audiences are “signals” you proactively added and which are “optimized” and found by AI. Use audience insights to see top segments to inform your creative assets and landing pages.

Fundamentals That Often Require Partnership

While they aren’t technically “controls” you can enable, your website, landing pages, product feed, conversion tracking set up and more, can have a huge influence on the success of your Performance Max campaigns.

Sure, it’s a cliche to say good advertising can’t fix a bad website, but AI introduces even more reasons to work closely with your developer, UX, CRO – and even finance – teams and colleagues (and an opportunity to expand your own skill set).

Website And Landing Pages

Your website and landing pages are now key sources for generated assets – automatically created assets and the newly launched generative asset creation for Performance Max – so you want to be sure they accurately reflect your brand, offerings, and differentiators.

Merchant Center Feeds

For retailers, your product feed assets are reflected directly in your ads, so having high-quality images, informative and unique product titles and descriptions, and of course, accurate pricing, shipping, and tax data are all critical to success with Performance Max.

If your image assets aren’t where you want them to be, check out Product Studio which just launched in Merchant Center and uses generative AI to create high-impact product imagery.

Lead Gen Quality Improvements

There are ongoing investments in measures to help reduce invalid leads.

In addition, there are some steps we recommend advertisers take to help prevent leads from users who don’t provide accurate information.

These steps include server-side validation, double opt-in, Recaptcha, and using enhanced conversions for leads with qualified and converted conversion categories.

Performance Max Continues To Evolve

As you can see, many levers, insights, and reporting features have been added to Performance Max since it launched two years ago – thanks in large part to advertiser feedback.

You can expect to see Performance Max continue to evolve to make it easier for advertisers to get more out of their campaigns.

More resources: 


Featured Image: BestForBest/Shutterstock

PPC Strategies For 2024: Insights From Over 16,000 Businesses via @sejournal, @lorenbaker

We’re diving into insights from over 16,000 ecommerce businesses, showing the trends that shaped PPC advertising in 2023, and how to use them to move forward into 2024.

In this insightful interview with Jacques van der Wilt, he and Loren examine highlights from DataFeedWatch’s powerful Multichannel Marketing Report. They take a look at which PPC strategies stood out the most and which channels provided the best return, along with big changes coming next year.

Using these insights, they also explore the most common challenges in ecommerce PPC campaigns, and what leading brands are doing to succeed right now.

We looked into the feeds of 15 to 20,000 online stores in all of those countries, and that means that’s such an incredible volume that what we see basically is an almost exact picture of what is happening in ecommerce advertising. – Jacques van der Wilt, 2:20

Obviously Google is still the largest channel. Almost every retailer is using that. However, we can see that social is beginning to eat their lunch. – Jacques van der Wilt, 6:06

I think Amazon has a big influence on everything. They’re probably market leader in ecommerce, so their impact must have been big. Yet I think that it’s not primarily driven by Amazon. – Jacques van der Wilt, 11:59

[0:00] About Jacques van der Wilt
[2:11] DataFeedWatch’s Multichannel Marketing Report
[6:06] Marketing channel trends
[9:14] Growth of TikTok
[13:42] The 3 largest barriers to PPC growth in 2024
[16:58] Other challenges retailers are facing
[21:40] Best tactics for PPC practioners to use in 2024
[25:02] Challenges for retailers with large inventories

Resources Mentioned:

Creating or modifying images with AI is super easy. Imagine you’re unhappy with your images as a retailer, but you have images for 10,000 products. It’s horrible. So you can do that much quicker. It’s a big time saver. – Jacques van der Wilt, 16:02

Connect with Jacques van der Wilt:

Jacques is a shopping feeds industry leader, start-up mentor, and entrepreneur. He’s the founder of DataFeedWatch (acquired by Cart.com in 2022): a leading global feed management and optimization company that helps online merchants optimize their product listings on more than 2000 shopping channels in over 60 countries. Before founding DataFeedWatch, Jacques held leadership positions in the US and Europe. He is also a seasoned guest speaker at industry events and a mentor at Startup Bootcamp.

Connect on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/vanderwilt/

Connect with Loren Baker:

Follow him on Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/lorenbaker

Connect with him on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorenbaker

Customer Generation: Experts Reveal Paid Media Strategies For SaaS Success via @sejournal, @hethr_campbell

Growing your customer base without draining your budget can be tough, especially in today’s dynamic market.

With constant search engine updates and ever-evolving user behaviors, how do you drive revenue for your business while keeping your customer acquisition costs low?

How do you know where to focus your ad spend for maximum ROI?

If you’re looking for a game-changing solution, join us on December 6 as we reveal a proven formula to help you supercharge your strategy. 

In this webinar, we’re cracking the code to customer acquisition and walking you through a unique methodology that has driven low-cost growth for hundreds of SaaS brands – from startups to publicly traded companies. 

Sign up and discover actionable ways to grow your pipeline and revenue (all backed by real data from over $150 million in SaaS ad spend per year!)

Here’s a sneak peek at what you’ll take away from this live presentation:

  • The Power of First-Party Data: Learn how and why leveraging first-party data rather than third-party data is the key to campaign success.
  • Financial Modeling with LTV:CAC: Discover how to analyze channel performance through use of the Customer Lifetime Value to Customer Acquisition Cost (LTV:CAC) ratio for better budget allocation that your CFO will love.
  • Getting Personal with Your Pipeline: Develop laser-focused psychological marketing tactics and use gift-giving to boldly identify and emotionally resonate with your precise target personas at your ideal accounts.

With Garrett Mehrguth, Co-Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Directive, we’ll dive into key insights on Customer Generation, the proven methodology that makes sure you never miss your growth goals again.

Get ready to unlock the secrets to SaaS success and arm yourself with the strategies you need to boost your customer base and revenue.

Attend live, and you’ll even get the chance to chat with your industry peers and ask Garrett your most burning questions.

Register now and access the expert tips to guide you through 2024 and beyond. Don’t miss out!

Mastering PPC In 2024: Trends To Inform Your Strategy via @sejournal, @sejournal

Navigating PPC isn’t easy.

No one has all the answers, but get enough experts together, and you can discover powerful PPC trends.

Which is exactly what we did.

As pay-per-click (PPC) marketing evolves with new trends constantly emerging, it can be hard to know where to focus your efforts.

What worked for your PPC campaigns in the past may no longer cut it.

Not only do consumers continue to change, but the technology available to marketers is always advancing – not to mention search engines and social media platforms throwing curveballs into the mix.

Between widespread adoption of AI, inflation in cost-per-click (CPC) budgets, and new shifts in user engagement, we’ve seen a lot of changes in 2023 that will shape your PPC strategy moving forward.

So, if you’re looking to get ahead in the dynamic world of PPC, the key is adapting and knowing when to pivot.

Download our PPC Trends ebook to access expert insights on what’s coming, what you should pay attention to, and what to avoid.

This sixth edition features commentary from 13 of the top PPC marketing experts. Inside are the latest developments over the past year and how you can leverage these trends in 2024 and beyond.

Let’s dive into three of the core ideas outlined in the ebook:

  • AI in PPC: The potential these new tools offer, along with the limitations that can lead to pitfalls.
  • How to control your budgets and maximize value amidst CPC inflation.
  • The new user engagement channels shaping PPC, and what you should focus on.

AI In PPC: Potential & Limitations

AI had its moment in the spotlight this year, with several shiny new AI features making their debut on PPC platforms. Marketers also began adopting generative AI in earnest.

But now that the dust is settling, we’re realizing that it’s not all black and white.

While some experts champion the benefits of AI, like automated ad campaigns, others advise caution.

AI has its strengths, but it’s not a universal fix – and human thinking and creativity still drive online interactions.

Here are three key AI insights from the ebook:

  • AI is very good at the things it’s good at, and very bad at the things it’s bad at.
  • AI is a square peg, so beware of round holes; AI is not a panacea.
  • AI can be a multiplier of productivity and results, but some processes are worth the difficulty.

So when it comes to AI, tread carefully, use it where it shines, and remember that the power of the human touch remains invaluable.

CPC Inflation: Controlling Budgets & Maximizing Value

Inflation has cast its shadow far and wide, from the grocery store to business supply chains – and even in your ad auctions.

As you brace for these rising costs, you can refer to this ebook for expert tips and guidance on how to navigate CPC inflation.

One key point to note is that it’s not always about directly seeking cheaper CPC prices, but rather extracting maximum value from your CPCs as they are.

Here are three key insights on CPC inflation:

  • Cost-cutting, for its own sake, isn’t always the way.
  • Don’t obsess over what you can’t control; make the higher cost worth it.
  • Don’t mindlessly follow the metrics fed to you. Validate your data.

Download PPC Trends 2024 to learn more.

Lean Into New Developments & New User Engagement Channels

With all the potential challenges on the horizon for 2024, diversification is a way you can insulate your businesses from disruption.

But broadening your channels and data sources is no small feat.

First, you need a crystal-clear cross-platform strategy, a unified messaging approach, and a consistent brand identity.

You must also be willing to experiment to discover positive and negative outcomes.

Plus, you’ll need buy-in from stakeholders to be flexible about key performance indicators (KPIs) – and be willing to engage in activity that’s more difficult to measure directly.

Here are three key insights on how you can lean into change, but in service of marketing strategies that have always been effective:

  • Meet people where they are isn’t a new concept, but it will require you to learn new platforms and new ways of engagement.
  • Stubborn adherence to one channel or one data source won’t work: You need new channels, new sources of data, and a model to draw insights from various sources.
  • Embrace the new in service of what you’ve always known about marketing.

Discover more of the trends that made waves in 2023 and are set to reshape the future of advertising.

Read expert insights from:

  • Akvile DeFazio, Founder, AKvertise.
  • Alex Macura, Founder/CEO, Your Digital Assembly.
  • Amalia Fowler, Principal Strategist, Good AF Consulting.
  • Amy Hebdon, Founder + Managing Director, Paid Search Magic.
  • Andrea Atzori, Director, Ambire.
  • Ben Steele, Senior Editor Ebooks, Search Engine Journal.
  • Ben Wood, Director of Growth & Innovation, Hallam.
  • Corey Morris, President/CEO, Voltage.
  • Ginny Marvin, Ads Product Liaison, Google.
  • Lauren Weisel, Director of SEM, Media.Monks.
  • Lisa Raehsler, Founder and SEM Strategy Consultant, Big Click Co.
  • Navah Hopkins, Evangelist, Optmyzr.
  • Tim Jensen, Sr. Search Marketing Specialist, M&T Bank.

Grab your copy of PPC Trends 2024 for expert insights and actionable tips to prepare for the year ahead.

Mastering PPC In 2024: Trends To Inform Your Strategy


Featured Image: Paulo Bobita/Search Engine Journal

Agile Budgeting: What It Is, Why It’s Impactful, And How To Make It Work For You As A Marketer via @sejournal, @adsliaison

You might have heard “agile budgeting” referenced during the keynotes at Google Marketing Live this year.

I had several people ask me about what it means – and some were skeptical when I explained a bit about it.

Is this just another buzzy term, or is there real value to it? Let’s dig in.

You may already be familiar with the concept of Agile in project management to prioritize project speed and enable the flexibility needed to quickly adapt to change.

Similarly, the goal of agile budgeting is to allow you to respond quickly to shifts in demand and prioritize spend in the areas of greatest opportunity.

Think:

  • Proactive rather than reactive.
  • Real-time rather than retrospective.
  • Unified rather than siloed.

I know, I know…hasn’t one of the great benefits of digital marketing always been about agility and the ability to quickly shift budgets, test, and iterate?

Yes, but the reality has also been that channels have typically been managed in silos, and budgets have often been planned over fixed time periods.

And, of course, there are AI advancements now enabling much faster responses to market shifts. This is causing many marketers to rethink what agility really looks like.

When you’re budget agile, you can respond much faster to market and business dynamics versus being constrained by fixed budgeting that’s based on a strict timeline, specific channel silos, and other constraints.

That’s a fundamental shift for many businesses and agencies – particularly for teams and individuals accustomed to working and budgeting by channel.

As with any new approach, agile budgeting requires re-thinking, re-organizing, and re-prioritizing.

Specifically, it requires tight coordination across marketing, sales, and operations – with marketing and finance, in particular, working closely together.

OK, But Is It Worth It?

Changing how your business plans, allocates, and optimizes digital budgets may sound daunting (small organizations are often at an advantage here!). Still, research shows that companies don’t have to make dramatic changes to become more budget-agile.

You can probably think of a few ways you can fairly easily tweak and improve certain behaviors in how you, your teams, and your agency work.

In fact, you may already be starting to practice agile budgeting even if you don’t have a formal process yet.

Agile budgeting is the concept behind AI-powered cross-channel campaigns such as Performance Max.

Instead of allocating a certain amount to each specific channel, your budget is applied dynamically wherever there is demonstrated customer demand.

The goal is to find incremental conversions or conversion value at your target regardless of channel.

To gauge how many marketers are considered budget agile and to better understand the factors in doing agile budgeting successfully, last year, Google partnered with Kantar to survey more than 2,400 marketers around the world.

In the study, marketers who adjust budgets across digital channels on a weekly or more frequent basis are considered behaviorally budget agile.

(You can see why close cross-functional coordination is important!)

Nearly a quarter of those surveyed met that standard.*

Some Quick Findings From The Survey

  • 31% of budget agile marketers engage in formal marketing planning to align on strategy and digital media budget allocations every month, versus 18% of non-agile marketers.
  • For 59% of budget agile marketers, digital budget changes of 20% or more take a week or longer for approval.
  • 31% of budget agile marketers say it’s “very easy” to get additional budget to start new tests that weren’t included in the initial media budget, compared to just 9% of non-agile marketers.
  • 48% of budget agile marketers state that their marketing performance exceeded internal expectations and marketing KPIs, compared to 33% of marketers who are not budget agile.
  • Budget agile marketers are twice as likely to call their marketing across channels “very tightly integrated.”
  • 42% of budget agile marketers say their agency partners greatly influence adjustments they make after initial budget planning, compared to only 31% of non-agile marketers.

Key Takeaways To Become More Budget Agile

AI advancements are opening up all types of new digital marketing opportunities, including multichannel campaigns, and with that, we see many organizations and agencies reevaluating their approaches to maximize ROI.

Here are the areas of focus identified from the survey that can set marketers on the path to greater agility:

Flexible, Frequent Planning

Agile budgeting doesn’t mean you throw your planning process out. It means you plan and prepare for change, providing space to adapt and shift as conditions change.

And it likely means increasing the frequency with which you revisit and adjust your plans.

Common Goals & Measurement

Align on the marketing goals that make sense for the business, such as sales revenue, profit margins, lifetime value, etc.

Then, implement consistent measurement and metrics across marketing and cross-functional teams to be able to assess and adjust together.

More Collaboration Across Teams

Being budget agile also doesn’t mean you need to move away from having in-house or agency teams and individuals focused on specific channels.

But breaking down organizational barriers to ensure those teams and individuals are collaborating, meeting, and sharing more regularly together is key. This takes commitment and effort but can start paying off quickly.

Strong Finance Partnership

Establishing trust, understanding, and close partnership with your CFO and finance teams is also key to being able to move toward budget agility.

Operational Alignment

As you can see from the data above – if not from your own experience – a big stumbling block to being budget agile is getting timely budget allocation or reallocation approvals.

Nearly 60% of budget agile marketers said digital budget changes of 20% or more take a week or longer for approval.

Getting a sizable budget approval in less than a week may sound Herculean, but consider if your competitors are among the 40% that can do so and seize on new opportunities to drive incremental value or experiment faster.

Experimentation Baked In

As digital marketers, we’re accustomed to running tests and experiments on an ongoing, regular basis.

But there’s nothing more frustrating than wanting to launch a new test or scale a promising one and running up against fixed budget constraints.

Nearly one-third of budget agile marketers said it’s “very easy” to get incremental budget to kick off new tests, versus less than 10% of non-agile marketers.

Again, this points to the value of aligning across the organization on goals, measurement, and an operational framework that will allow you to move faster.

Bringing flexible planning and budgeting processes into your digital advertising efforts will allow you to laser focus on driving growth by allowing you to readjust your forecasts and invest where opportunities crop up with greater speed and coordination.

The payoff can be worth the effort to get there.

More resources:


Featured Image: fizkes/Shutterstock

*Google/Kantar, Budget Agility and Channel Desiloing research, AU, BR, CA, DE, IN, JP, U.K., U.S., advertiser: digital display n=1,747, social media n=1,936, search n=1,513, online video n=1,538, mobile-only formats (e.g., in-app advertising) n=907, streaming/connected TV n=230, other digital n=2,093, March 2022–June 2022.